Weekly newsletter

OSCE: Hungary Elections Well-Run but Did Not Offer Level Playing Field

MTI-Hungary Today 2022.04.05.

Hungary’s parliamentary elections were well-run but the electoral process was marred by the absence of a level playing field, the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) said on Monday.

Candidates were largely able to campaign freely but the tone of the campaign was negative, OSCE election and referendum monitor Kari Henriksen told a press conference assessing the ballot.

She said a lack of transparency and oversight over campaign finance favored the ruling alliance.

K-Monitor: Governing Parties Spent 8 Times More on Billboard Campaigns Than Opposition
K-Monitor: Governing Parties Spent 8 Times More on Billboard Campaigns Than Opposition

The spendings on the Fidesz-KDNP side are some three times more than the limit set by law, if you add in the clearly pro-party ads of pro-Fidesz NGO CÖF and the govt's advertisements which also share Fidesz-KDNP's messages.Continue reading

The absence of debates between the main contestants limited the ability of voters to make an informed decision, Henriksen said. She said the OSCE had also observed that women had been underrepresented among the candidates and in the campaign overall. In order for voters to be able to make an informed choice it is crucial that candidates get equal access to the media, she said.

Henriksen added, however, that the observation mission’s findings were mainly positive and that it had witnessed few violations of the rules.

Mark Pritchard, head of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly’s delegation, said the election had been organized successfully but showed many shortcomings, with numerous prior recommendations made by the organization yet to be addressed.

He encouraged the incoming government to be more ambitious when it came to improving election laws.

OSCE: Unequal Election Opportunities in Hungary
OSCE: Unequal Election Opportunities in Hungary

The report notes that the relevant law on campaign finances does not regulate spending by third parties who play an active role in the campaign.Continue reading

Jillian Stark, head of the election observation mission deployed by OSCE’s Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR), said the election had been overshadowed by a blurring of the line between the ruling parties and the state.

She said the observers had heard a variety of opinions, adding that they had come to Hungary to observe the election, not to interfere with it.

Stark said the legal framework for holding a referendum on the same day as the election was “inadequate for a democratic process”, adding that voters had not received balanced information about the ballot.

The high turnout, however, demonstrates the commitment of Hungarian voters, she said.

Stark also said it was “shocking” how polarised people’s views were on the Russia-Ukraine war.

Press Roundup: OSCE Observers Release Negative Interim Report on Campaign Conditions in Hungary
Press Roundup: OSCE Observers Release Negative Interim Report on Campaign Conditions in Hungary

Pro-government outlets see the interim report by OSCE observers as heavily biased. The left-wing daily finds such rebuttals hypocritical.Continue reading

Voting process was smooth, says intl observer

Voting in Hungary’s April 3 general election and referendum went smoothly and efficiently, Russell Nobile, a senior attorney at the American conservative think-tank Judicial Watch, said in Budapest on Tuesday.

Nobile told a press conference that Judicial Watch had found no problems with the voting process in general, and that voting in Hungary had been better organized than it often was in certain parts of the United States.

The representatives of the various political parties cooperated with each other at polling stations, he said, adding that voters had not had to wait long to cast their ballots.

Nobile said Judicial Watch’s observation mission had not extended to the policies, situation or media presence of the parties.

FM Szijjártó Sends Warning to EU Diplomats Planning to Observe Election
FM Szijjártó Sends Warning to EU Diplomats Planning to Observe Election

Szijjártó said they should not "walk around in the voting districts and give their opinions on what is right and wrong, because their job is to represent their nation, to build bilateral relations out of mutual respect and based on mutual interests."Continue reading

The think-tank applied the same methods in their mission as they do in the US, Nobile said, adding that Judicial Watch’s focus was on whether voters were able to cast their ballots and under which circumstances.

Judicial Watch does not concern itself with the outcome of the election, Nobile said. Its focus in the US is mainly on the protection of transparency and the rule of law, he added.

Polish analysts: Election complied with local, international norms

Hungary’s general election and referendum met all local and international norms and standards, according to a Polish analysis based on reports by international election monitors.

The election was available to all voters and was free and fair, as well as meeting privacy requirements, the report released on Monday said.

Polish Election Observer: OSCE Assumes Narrative of the Hungarian Opposition
Polish Election Observer: OSCE Assumes Narrative of the Hungarian Opposition

Jerzy Kwaśniewski argues that international organizations such as the OSCE distinguish Central and Eastern European countries as "new" democracies, and thus try to babysit political processes.Continue reading

Election monitors expressed concern, however, about an attack on the ruling Fidesz party’s website and a text message campaign carried out by the opposition, the Ordo Iuris institute and its partner, the Collegium Intermarium, said.

Nothing took place on election day to violate fair and free voting, they added.

Also, in the year preceding election day, no changes were made to the election law which could have undermined the electoral system’s stability or the rule of law, the report said.

Featured photo illustration by Attila Balázs/MTI


Array
(
    [1536x1536] => Array
        (
            [width] => 1536
            [height] => 1536
            [crop] => 
        )

    [2048x2048] => Array
        (
            [width] => 2048
            [height] => 2048
            [crop] => 
        )

)