Weekly newsletter

Justice Minister: Hungary Maintains Position that Passage of Sargentini Report Was Unlawful

MTI-Hungary Today 2020.12.03.

The Hungarian government maintains its position that the European Parliament’s launch of the Article 7 procedure against Hungary in 2018 was unlawful because its vote on the Sargentini report, which served as the basis for the procedure, disregarded the abstentions of 48 deputies, Justice Minister Judit Varga said on Thursday.

Varga insisted the voting procedure had been in conflict not only with the EU treaties but with the procedural rules of the EP itself. If abstentions had been taken into consideration, the EP’s “politically motivated position” could not have been adopted.

The minister was reacting to an opinion published by the advocate general of the Court of Justice of the European Union earlier in the day, in which Michal Bobek advised that the court should dismiss Hungary’s challenge of the Article 7 procedure.

Advocate General Advises EU Court to Dismiss Hungarian Action on Article 7 Procedure
Advocate General Advises EU Court to Dismiss Hungarian Action on Article 7 Procedure

The Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has advised the court to dismiss Hungary’s challenge of the European Parliament’s Article 7 procedure against the country. In his opinion published on Thursday, Michal Bobek noted that the EP launched an Article 7 procedure against Hungary in 2018, citing “a clear […]Continue reading

Varga noted the EP had earlier claimed the Article 7 procedure could not be challenged in court. The fact that Bobek declared Hungary’s claim admissible was welcome, she said, insisting at the same time that Bobek’s view on abstentions was unfounded. In his interpretation, an abstaining deputy “wishes to be treated as if they had not voted at all”, she said, insisting that an abstention was in fact a form of participation in the vote, “a clear declaration of support neither for votes in favour nor votes against”. Further, it was “irrelevant”, she said, that the deputies had been informed about abstentions being set aside since “that is against EU law”. The EP, she insisted, had failed to clarify those details before the vote.

The Hungarian government is “convinced that EU laws apply to all”, Varga said, adding that “agreeing with the EP’s overlooking rules in a procedure concerning the rule of law would be especially absurd.”

featured image via Szilárd Koszticsák/MTI


Array
(
    [1536x1536] => Array
        (
            [width] => 1536
            [height] => 1536
            [crop] => 
        )

    [2048x2048] => Array
        (
            [width] => 2048
            [height] => 2048
            [crop] => 
        )

)